Organic Tartar Sauce

Some of the links in this post are affiliate links. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. All opinions remain my own.

Filled with the goodness of natural extracts, organic tartar sauce is one of the best sauces you can add to your kitty. It is made from various pickles, mayonnaise, capers, and olives, which gives this sauce its iconic spicy & sour taste.

But there is an abundance of variety to choose from organic tartar sauce. And a normal consumer can easily get lost with a plethora of options at disposal. Being the experts, we did the researched and shortlisted best organic tartar sauces you can buy, below:

How Can The Organic Tartar Sauce Be Used

  • Side Dipping – One of the primary uses of tartar sauce is a dipping sauce. You can use the tartar sauce with chicken Fries, pasta, burgers, or basically any snack you enjoy eating.
  • Cooking Sauce – Thanks to its spicy and smoky flavor, you can use tartar sauce in dishes as well. Many Italian dishes like pasta use this sauce as their main taste enhancer. Moreover, organic pasta sauce is a perfect choice as well.
  • Marinade – The tartar sauce can also be used for marinating food items like chicken, pork, beef, and lamb chops. This sauce is widely used as a secondary-marinating sauce as well.

Why Organic Tartar Sauce?

There are multiple reasons why you should pick an Organic Tartar Sauce instead of a regular mayonnaise sauce, and we have mentioned some of them below:

  • Wide range of flavor – An tartar sauce has a wide range of flavors as it offers a unique taste profile. Depending on the variant you pick, a tartar sauce may taste spicy, sweet, or sour.
  • Fewer Shady Items – The natural tartar sauces that we buy have at least 2 shady items that are not included in the description compared to tartar sauces, which only have 0.8.
  • Provides a more organic taste – These sauces give us a more earthy flavor of the ingredients included in it because there are not many added preservatives.
  • Less Side effects – Organic tartar sauces contain mostly organic extracts usually have zero to very few side effects on our body in the long run when compared to a normal sauce, which can contain many harmful chemicals at once.

Buying Considerations for Organic Tartar Sauce

  • Low sugar and sodium – Sugar and sodium are two essential things to consider while buying tartar sauce. A healthy tartar sauce should have less than 5 grams of sugar per serving. On the other hand, the sodium content should be more than 250 mg per 2 tbsp serving.
  • Ingredients – When you buy tartar sauce and cannot understand the names of ingredients. Most probably, you are looking at the wrong product. The ingredients that should be a part of a healthy tartar sauce should be natural. Some of them are mayonnaise, ketchup, chopped pickles, apple cider vinegar, black pepper, mustard, and lemon juice. Don’t choose the one that has Molasses or corn syrup.
  • Blends well with the food – Your choice of tartar sauce also depends on the type of food you are using it with. Choose the spicy and smoky sauce if you are eating meat. Go for the sweet and fruity version if you are fond of vegetables.

Reviews: Best Organic Tartar Sauce

So, based on our research, We have compiled a list of the best organic tartar sauce you can buy. Just a quick word, we collect a minimal amount of profit through every purchase that is made through the links mentioned below, without any additional charges on you. That said, let’s start with our list.

Reviewed by: John Max Score: 99.2

  • Thanks to its authentic taste, this organic taste has a very natural essence.
  • It is specially made to be used as a seasoning sauce thanks to its thick consistency.
  • The flavor of this sauce is slightly more salty than sweet, which gives it a unique outlook.
  • It comes in a rigid container that is suitable for traveling as well.
  • This sauce is completely organic and certified, so you don’t have to worry about any allergies.

Rating CategoryWeight %Score
Total Score100%97.25


Stonewell Kitchen® Legal Organic Tartar Sauce

  • The creamy consistency of this sauce makes it perfect for seasoning in burgers and sandwiches,
  • It has a very well-balanced flavor, and it never overpowers other flavors mixed with it.
  • It comes in a big container that will surely last you for a long time.
  • The fragrance of this tartar sauce is very farm-like and fresh.
  • Many certified chefs and food institutions have acclaimed this sauce.

Rating CategoryWeight %Score
Total Score100%96.5


Kraft® Fresh Organic Tartar Sauce

  • With zero harmful preservatives, this organic tartar sauce is one of the best in terms of purity.
  • It has a spicy flavor due to the olives and jalapenos extracts present in it.
  • You can use this sauce with literally any food item thanks to its light taste pattern.
  • The consistency of this sauce is really light and smooth, which makes it apt for seasonings.
  • For the price, you get a lot of organic tartar sauce that will last you for a long time.

Rating CategoryWeight %Score
Total Score100%95.5


Follow Your Heart® Soy Free Organic Tartar Sauce

  • This soy-free tartar sauce has a very delicious and long-lasting flavor
  • It is Non-GMO, so you don’t have to worry about the quality of the ingredients used in this sauce.
  • It comes in a convenient jar that is travel-friendly, and you can easily store it anywhere.
  • It is made to be used as an individual seasoning sauce due to its perfect consistency.


The Ojai Cook® Spicy Flavoured Tartar Organic Sauce

  • Thanks to its rich texture, this sauce has a very organic taste and essence.
  • The flavor of this tartar sauce will surely last for a long time due to the pickle extracts present in it.
  • It comes in a big-enough box that will last you for at least 100 regular servings.
  • You can use this sauce in sandwiches, burgers, pizzas, and pasta, depending on your preference.
  • This tartar sauce comes in a pack-of-2, that too at a very reasonable price.


Whole Food® Organic Tartar Sauce

  • The taste of this sauce is very well-balanced between spicy and sweet.
  • It comes in a big jar, which allows you to use this tartar sauce for as long as you want.
  • The consistency of this tartar sauce is very thick, and you can even taste the parsley extracts in it.
  • This sauce comes in multiple variants so that you can choose the perfect one for yourself.
  • It has a robust and empowering flavor, which amplifies the taste of your food item,


365 by Whole Foods Market® Organic Tartar Sauce

  • This is a pack of Organic Tartar Sauce, made by 365 by Whole Foods Market.
  • It comes in a fresh and new packaging, while the product quality is maintained at the highest level.
  • The sauce is made with high-quality ingredients, including Organic Soybean, and Sweet Relish.
  • It is Certified Organic, Vegan-friendly, and goes great with Seafood.


Stonewall Kitchen Store® House Tartar Sauce

  • This is a 7.75oz pack of Stonewall Kitchen Store House Tartar Sauce,
  • It is creamy yet tangy, and formulated with inspiration from Legal Sea Foods’ classic in-house recipe.
  • The sauce features herbaceous Dill and course-cut Pickle Relish, in an Aioli-like base.
  • It also includes Salted eggs, and goes great with sea foods of all kind, especially a fish sandwich.


INGLEHOFFER® Seafood Tartar Sauce

  • This is a bottle of Seafood Tartar Sauce created by INGLEHOFFER.
  • The sauce is a creamy and tangy blend of mayonnaise, capers and lemon for ultimate rich flavors.
  • It is made from fresh ingredients, and comes in travel-friendly bottles with flip caps.
  • The sauce is Kosher, Vegetarian, Low-calorie, Gluten-Free, Trans fat-free, and low in cholesterol and preservatives.


Captain Toady's® Tasty Sauces Tartar Sauce

  • This is a pack of Tasty Sauces Tartar Sauce, created by Captain Toady’s.
  • It delivers pure gourmet goodness, brought directly from the great Northwest.
  • The sauce is made with a blend of natural ingredients, and fruit concentrates for rich taste.
  • It is long-lasting and shelf-stable.

Index Table: Top-Rated Organic Tartar Sauce

1Frisch's Original - Organic Tartar Sauce
  • Seasoning Special
  • Salty Flavour
2Stonewell Kitchen Legal Organic - Tartar Sauce
  • Creamy
  • Award-winning
Stonewell Kitchen98.5
3Kraft Fresh - Organic Tartar Sauce
  • Zero Preservatives
  • Spicy
4Follow Your Heart Soy Free - Organic Tartar Sauce
  • Non-GMO
  • Gluten Free
Follow Your Heart97.8
5The Ojai Cook Spicy Flavoured - Tartar Organic Sauce
  • Cage-Free
  • Jalapeno Extracts
The Ojai Cook97.4
6Whole Food Organic - Tartar Sauce
  • All Natural
  • Packaged
Whole Food96.6
7365 by Whole Foods Market Organic - Tartar Sauce
  • Organic Soybean
  • Sweet Relish
365 by Whole Foods Market96.2
8Stonewall Kitchen Store House - Tartar Sauce
  • Sweet Pickle Relish
  • Salted Eggs
Stonewall Kitchen Store95.9
9INGLEHOFFER Seafood - Tartar Sauce
  • Fresh Ingredients
  • Kosher
10Captain Toady's Tasty Sauces - Tartar Sauce
  • Natual Ingredients
  • Fruit Concentrates
Captain Toady's95.1

About the Author

John Max

John Max is a registered dietitian and certified strength and conditioning specialist based out of Manhattan, NY. He understands the difference the right organic products make towards the fitness and comfort of the human body. He reads a lot of stuff on the internet to explore and stay updated with the latest advancements in the organic industry. John also regularly tests and analyzes the benefits and features of as many organic products as possible. Without a surprise, many of our readers love his reviews and testing style for how thorough and straightforward they are.